Obama should promote A.A. for MTP

First of all, I respect who Tim Russert was as a person and a journalist.  He created a legacy that matters to this country.

I would note however that I resented his insertion of opinion in the guise of "facts" (often within loaded questions),  and ultimately mislead the American People on numerous issues such as social security, abortion, and politics in general.  He certainly had the right to determine which "facts" that he felt appropriate to highlight, but as his power increased, he should have been humble enough to realize that others were misusing his characterizations as facts and he began to "make the news" and "shape the conventional wisdom" rather than being a journalist.

His repeating the Obama line about  how Superdelegates wouldn't want to overturn the  will of the people as shown by his tally of  "elected delegates" was an example of his work.  Sure, many Democrats in power said that, but mostly it was spin that became reality through people like Russert.  Russert could have just as easily been on a rampage to show how "elected delegates" didn't represent the will of the elected people (Nevada, Texas,Was.,Neb.) , and this election would have been totally different.

Also, his patented questions about politicians' positions on abortion were very narrow and again limited the parameters of the discussion.  Often, he would ask Republicans "do you support exceptions for rape and life of the mother" or "what penalties would there be for a woman who had an abortion".  For Democrats he would ask the when do you believe life begins question.

He was better than most are today, but again he became too much of an institution in and of himself.

My critique on this issue is that there are many follow ups that he never went into, and many other areas he left untouched that should have been explored.  But it was as though, if Tim Russert didn't ask it, then it really doesn't matter.

For instance:

(pro life side)

Ask Republicans: in a real sense, "aren't you and the party pro-choice?  You promise to uphold the current law with your oath, Republicans have controlled government at all levels over the past 20 years, and we still have over 1 million abortions each year?  We have seen Republicans go to great lengths to cut taxes under every possible economic circumstance, why aren't you that committed to reducing and eliminating abortions?

or

challenging liberal democrats who advocate government help for the weakest among us to extend that to unborn children.

(pro choice side)

How could you possibly argue that the removal of  undifferented cells  from a woman's body is the moral equalivalent of murder, when the average woman has numerous "spontaneous abortions" (miscarriages) in her lifetime oftentimes not even missing a menstrual cycle?

If you believe that a human life begins at conception and deserves protection under the law, then why not name the baby at the first recognition of pregnancy, and have funerals and death certificates for every known miscarriage?

Would you want to live in an America where the government actually tried to stop all abortions?

The above questions include my opinions, but I make an effort to expand the range of legitimate questions and include more perspective.  Tim Russert was one person who became bigger than his profession.

Of course, that is really more our and the rest of the political world's fault and not Tim's.  

So God Bless Tim Russert.
 A job well done.

--
Looking Forward, I've heard all the speculation about:

Andrea Mitchell
Chuck Todd
Chris Matthews
Tom Brokaw

But no African American. No Latino. No Asian.

Also:No different "Types of people" like:

An overweight woman, a disabled person, a western conservative, a southern liberal,etc.,

Barack Obama (at the appropriate time of course) should take this opportunity to establish his understanding of Affirmative Action.

I hope it is:

1. a well qualified person
2. a person who brings life experience to a job or position that traditionally has been excluded or overlooked.

The beauty of our country is that we have included many more people in power than others around the world.  This gives us a better chance at success.  At solving big problems, making big discoveries, and in general prospering.  There's no reason an unattractive-overweight person can't be a great t.v. personality but there's a bias against them.  

Race and gender are the biggest issue with affirmative action and rightfully so.  But I want to people, especially Obama to establish that the principle to make sure every person has an equal chance to reach their God-given potential.

The short list for the next MTP host is very traditional and "inside Washington".

Barrack Obama can be an agent for change today by delineating how America benefits when we truly consider all qualified people for every important position.

Tim Russert made his position very important, even in ways that I disagree.  But now we need to make sure every person has a chance to grow up being a Tim Russert.

Senator Obama you can help with a great speech on this topic, and while you should definitely include race and gender, it should be expanded to included many more Americans now being left out but have talent to succeed.

Here's another short list:

Harold Ford
Gerry Nadler
Juan Williams
Connie Chung
Shelby Steele
Katie Couric
Clarence Page
Barbara Lee
Mike Huckabee
Hillary Clinton



Display:


This sounds like a great way to tank Obama. (2.00 / 2)

He is running for presidnet, not spokesman of Teh Blacks. An equally relevant suggestion would be for Clinton or Pelosi to make a speech urging a woman anchor. Makes absolutely no sense.


should we go outside? / should we break some bread? / are you'nterested?
by Firewall on Sun Jun 15, 2008 at 09:53:45 PM EST

Re: This sounds like a great way to tank Obama. (none / 0)

It might also do for everyone to note that the diarist is NOT an Obama supporter, but rather someone who has written several diaries attempting to undermine him throughout the primaries.

This is just a continuation of the attempted sabotage, but for the general election.


should we go outside? / should we break some bread? / are you'nterested?
by Firewall on Sun Jun 15, 2008 at 10:43:06 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: This sounds like a great way to tank Obama. (none / 0)

It is absolutely bizarre to suggest that elected officials should weigh in on who should scrutinize them.


by Adam B on Mon Jun 16, 2008 at 11:04:09 AM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Obama should promote A.A. for MTP (none / 0)

Not because of Obama...but I really like Gwen Ifill for the job


Matthew25Network.com
by cardboard 1 on Sun Jun 15, 2008 at 09:55:43 PM EST

Re: Obama should promote A.A. for MTP (none / 0)

For purely partisan reasons, I'm not a big fan of Ifill.  It seems like she gave Kerry (in 2004) and Obama a much harder time than was deserved.  It may be that she supports them but feels the need to distance herself or that she merel dislikes them.  Also, I feel like she doesn't follow up after her questions as much as she could (a major Russert problem).

I like Chuck Todd but he's probably too much of a horserace guy for my liking.


by Can I Haz Moar Snark on Sun Jun 15, 2008 at 10:11:56 PM EST
[ Parent ]

I despise Ifill (none / 0)

She has on at least two occasions completely rewritten history about the 2004 Veep debate to suggest that Edwards was baiting Cheney about his daughter and gay marriage, when Edwards was responding to a question Ifill had asked Cheney (and Cheney in real time thanked Edwards for his gracious reply). It's a remarkable case-study in how the CW can rewrite someone's own memory, but it also proves her basic unfitness for the job.

That said, she'd certainly be no worse than Russert or any names I've seen floated as his replacement, with the exception of Brokaw, who probably doesn't want it.


by BlueinColorado on Mon Jun 16, 2008 at 12:22:35 AM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Obama should promote A.A. for MTP (none / 0)

Mike Huckabee

Uh...what?


Users who are excessively bashing the Democratic Party, or being Republican trolls, will be banned.
by Massadonious on Sun Jun 15, 2008 at 09:56:32 PM EST

Not before Bobby Jindal. (none / 0)

He's performed real life exorcisms...what better experience for an exorcist of lies and deceit on Meet The Press?


should we go outside? / should we break some bread? / are you'nterested?
by Firewall on Sun Jun 15, 2008 at 09:57:29 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Good point. I'm supporting (none / 0)

Huckabee/Jindal for exorcists in Chief!


by semiquaver on Sun Jun 15, 2008 at 10:44:35 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Obama should promote A.A. for MTP (none / 0)

You lost me with "how "elected delegates" didn't represent the will of the elected people (Nevada, Texas,Was.,Neb.) , and this election would have been totally different"
It's time to move on we are in the G.E. now. By trying to rehash the primary you are only feeding the troll who are here to try and divide us.

by venician on Sun Jun 15, 2008 at 09:56:44 PM EST

Russert is the point (2.00 / 1)

he took a political point of view.

which is fine.

but he could have easily took another political point of view.

my point is we should have different people making these judgements than the regular crowd.

obama can help that along.


by yellowdem1129 on Sun Jun 15, 2008 at 09:58:37 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Obama should promote A.A. for MTP (2.00 / 1)

Its not at all clear to me why the new host of MTP should be an affirmative action pick, rather than simply the most qualified human being.

Don't get me wrong; I support affirmative action policies, in general.  But affirmative action is generally supposed to remedy some specific past discrimination.  Is that the case here?  Or are we just picking a black guy because he's a black guy?


by XoFalconXo on Sun Jun 15, 2008 at 09:57:00 PM EST

exactly what I was thinking (none / 0)

as such political correctness, which sometimes reaches beyong affirmative actions original purpose is what makes liberalism look bad. Plus, I see a ton of black commentators on TV today anyway.


by Lakrosse on Sun Jun 15, 2008 at 10:14:58 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Yes, there is specific discrimination in (none / 0)

the news/pundit business......

MOST positons....from MTP, to the other networks political discussion shows, to nightly news shows, to cable news shows are anchored by mostly white males.
Stephanopolous, Bob Schiefer, Russert, dominated the  network Sunday discussions with a bit of Matthews added.  ALL WHITE MALES.
Weekdays we have Blitzer, Cooper, Matthews, Dobbs, Gregory, and so on and so and FOX.

So tell me how there is NOT discrimination in the NEWS business  There are now a few women who get a show, and a few minority men..but they do not get the prime time shows, the major network shows.
And the women that occasionally get shows are few and far between....most get to be "guests"


by Jjc2008 on Sun Jun 15, 2008 at 10:37:18 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Yes, there is specific discrimination in (none / 0)

Pointing to a small handful of examples of white hosts does not make out a case for discrimination.  The word itself implies some sort of intentional and/or malicious action.  And what is our population sample here anyway?  There are a tiny number of prime time news shows.  I haven't seen any evidence that the profession in general discriminates against minorities.

And how about the population of potential, qualified MTP hosts?  What percentage of them are black/white/latino/etc.?  

You're painting with a very broad brush if you are going to cry discrimination every time you see half a dozen white guys doing the same job.


by XoFalconXo on Sun Jun 15, 2008 at 10:53:31 PM EST
[ Parent ]

You have got to be kidding (none / 0)

Or are you just really young???

We, women/minorities, have been decrying that lack of diverse voices on air for decades.  Hiring Katie Couric was a BIG deal for a reason.

I cannot believe you honestly believe there is not, has not but discrimination in this field.


by Jjc2008 on Mon Jun 16, 2008 at 08:30:17 AM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Obama should promote A.A. for MTP (none / 0)

It's not the worst idea to at least consider a person of color or a woman, "affirmative action pick" aside (and no, I don't like your phrasing of that at all).  Take a look at the media.  Ever notice how white it is?

That said, Obama's way too smart to get involved in this stuff.


No Way. No How. No McCain.
by Denny Crane on Mon Jun 16, 2008 at 01:30:08 AM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Obama should promote A.A. for MTP (none / 0)

Its not my phrasing; its the diarist's.  And just to reiterate my point - if you're considering race in making hiring decisions without any evidence of past discrimination by that employer/profession, you yourself are guilty of discrimination.  

Thats the law.


by XoFalconXo on Mon Jun 16, 2008 at 08:33:39 AM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Obama should promote A.A. for MTP (2.00 / 1)

Juan Williams? Sweet Jesus what a lousy idea.


by xdem on Sun Jun 15, 2008 at 09:57:45 PM EST

The only person (none / 0)

that works for me is Brian Lamb.


by Coldblue on Sun Jun 15, 2008 at 10:04:37 PM EST

Re: Obama should promote A.A. for MTP (none / 0)

"Americans now being left out" include Katie Couric and Connie Chung?  Good satire has to be at least somewhat close to believable...


by username on Sun Jun 15, 2008 at 10:06:33 PM EST

I say (none / 0)

drag Brokaw in, so that he can show these hacks and clowns what JOURNALISM IS!


Washington Woman

Progressive Blue

by kevin22262 on Sun Jun 15, 2008 at 10:15:58 PM EST

The President has no business (none / 0)

interfering in matters of the Press.


by activatedbybush on Sun Jun 15, 2008 at 10:25:21 PM EST

This is not the time.... (none / 0)

...to be slamming Russert, even if you predicate your slams with faux compliments.

As for Obama promoting anyone for the job... huh? Since when is it a good idea for a Presidential candidate to start trying to throw their weight around regarding who the next anchor of a news show should be?

Sounds like a very bad idea to me.


by Mystylplx on Sun Jun 15, 2008 at 10:36:49 PM EST

H*ll no to Fox talking head (none / 0)

Juan Williams. Of everyone on both lists I like Clarence Page the best!

The show seems to pride itself on having a "serious", buttoned up host, someone who is frankly pretty "vanilla", the personality doesn't overshadow the interviewee nor the subject matter. I see no inclination on their part to change what they've been doing. Page is a serious, straightforward newsman. I think he'd be -- by NBC's standards -- a revolutionary choice.


by Dmitri in San Diego on Sun Jun 15, 2008 at 10:52:33 PM EST

Re: Obama should promote A.A. for MTP (none / 0)

it will be either
david gregory
andrea mitchell
or chuck todd

these three are the only well known nbc anchors who have a clean enough, and unbiased as possible career.
 david gregory seems likely, but andrea mitchell is universally respected


by theninjagoddess on Sun Jun 15, 2008 at 11:18:00 PM EST

Re: Obama should promote A.A. for MTP (none / 0)

Your list of potential replacements is absolutely horrible, a grotesque menagerie of right-wing hacks and no-wing has-beens.

If you want a minority to fill the seat, Gwen Ifill is the obvious choice. She's a veteran of the show as well as an accomplished, intelligent journalist.


by Stroszek on Mon Jun 16, 2008 at 01:30:15 AM EST

Re: Obama should promote A.A. for MTP (none / 0)

It isn't Obama's place to lobby for the next host of MTP.

And is there nothing you concerners won't try to exploit in order to attack Obama?


Anybody's vote is worth having. But not everybody's vote is worth campaigning for.
by Freespeechzone on Mon Jun 16, 2008 at 02:18:33 AM EST

WTF? (2.00 / 1)

Sorry, you lost me at "a presidential candidate should pick the replacement anchor for a news show."

Seriously - WTF?

Who's minding the goddamn store around here?  This place is becoming a romper room for fourth-grader diarists.


by spunkmeyer on Mon Jun 16, 2008 at 02:58:14 AM EST

Re: Obama should promote A.A. for MTP (none / 0)

I think Obama needs to give a speech about next years season of American Idol.  I fully expect our Presidential nominee to promote entertainers of all stripes.


And so, may evil beware and may good dress warmly and eat lots of fresh vegetables.
by thatpurplestuff on Mon Jun 16, 2008 at 03:04:55 AM EST

Re: Obama should promote A.A. for MTP (none / 0)

In NBC had any balls.....they would give the job to Rachel Maddow


"I am standing with Barack Obama to say, `Yes, we can!'" Hillary Clinton 6/7/08
by feliks on Mon Jun 16, 2008 at 06:16:00 AM EST


You are not logged in.

In order to post a comment, you must be logged in. If you have a member account, please log in to comment.

If not, you can make an account right here. It's quick and free.